, , , ,

The Essay as Collage: Benjamin’s Fragmented Exploration

Walter Benjamin, a luminary in post-critical allegory-collage, intricately wove diverse insights, foreseeing 20th-century artistic demands. His avant-garde use of collage in “One-Way Street” defied conventions, blurring academic boundaries. Embracing essays, he rejected closure, presenting mosaics reflecting society’s fragments. Benjamin’s ideas, shockingly relevant, resonate in our complex digital age, guiding artistic exploration.


min read


Walter Benjamin, an indubitably eminent luminary in the domain of post-critical allegory-collage, stands as the primal progenitor of this singular form of artistic expression. The perspicacious insights and theories proffered by Benjamin within the realm of art criticism have, beyond a shadow of a doubt, etched an indelible imprint upon the artistic landscape, infusing it with a sumptuous tapestry of ideas that persist in their capacity to both provoke and inspire. As a visionary of his era, Benjamin evinced a profound comprehension of the allegorical imagination pervasive in German Baroque playwrights, concurrently presaging the artistic requisites that would come to delineate the unfolding tapestry of the twentieth century.

Benjamin, with a discerning acuity, identified an affinity between the oeuvre of Franz Kafka, resonating with a kindred timbre, and the emblematically enigmatic symbols adroitly deployed by German Baroque playwrights. Furthermore, Benjamin perceived an analogy between the melancholic spirit summoned by these artistic manifestations and the montage principle incarnated in the oeuvres of Sergei Eisenstein and Bertolt Brecht. In Benjamin’s estimation, montage arose as the contemporary incarnation of allegory, conferring upon the artist the potency to conjoin disparate elements in a manner that “shocks” the spectator into novel insights and apprehensions, thereby ushering forth novel realms of comprehension.

In his antecedent opus “One-Way Street,” Benjamin adroitly availed himself of the collage/montage modality to obfuscate the demarcations between sundry artistic forms. In this endeavor, he confronted and assailed the orthodox conceptualization of the scholarly tome, depicting it as naught but an antiquarian interlocutor amid two discrete filing systems. In an endeavor to transcend subjectivity, Benjamin ingeniously compiled a compendium constituted entirely of citations, thereby allowing the self to serve as a conduit for the expression of “objective cultural trends.” This stratagem bears a semblance to Roland Barthes’ creative undertaking in “A Lover’s Discourse: Fragments,” wherein the distillation of subjective experiences into linguistic fragments constituted the focal point of his artistic enterprise.

Indeed, the critics of the Modernist epoch grappled with a quandary apropos representation, and Benjamin’s divergence from the strictures of conventional book formats stands testament to his rejoinder. By embracing the essay as his favored mode of expression, Benjamin willingly embraced incompleteness and digression, eschewing the imperative of conclusive proofs or terminations. Thus, his essays metamorphosed into veritable mosaics, amalgamating fragments culled from every stratum of contemporary society into a complex gestalt that defied facile categorization.

The profundity of Benjamin’s observations and methodologies resounds resolutely within my contemplative recesses, impelling me toward further cogitation regarding their implications. His asseveration that montage and collage serve as efficacious vehicles for artistic expression reverberates potently. Through the juxtapolitical conjoining of disparate elements, Benjamin exemplifies the potentiality for the engenderment of new insights and the arousal of innovative perspectives. Benjamin, in effect, resuscitates a world saturated with preconceived notions and ossified frameworks, engendering alternative narratives that impugn entrenched paradigms.

Furthermore, the intellect is captivated by Benjamin’s emphasis on the inherent “shock” intrinsic to the act of forging connections between entities disparate. In an epoch characterized by an excess of readily accessible information, predominantly consumed in fragmentary guise, the capacity to forge connections that flout preconceived notions assumes a preeminent station. Benjamin’s conceptualization of allegory-collage as a mechanism for jolting the audience into novel recognitions and comprehensions harmonizes with the transformative potentiality inherent to art itself. Through the artistic modality of collage, wherein incongruous elements coexist within a singular spatial framework, Benjamin enjoins us to embrace the unexpected, discordant, and unconventional.

Additionally, Benjamin’s predilection for the essay over the traditional book format epitomizes a broader paradigm shift in our approach to the genesis and dissemination of knowledge. In an epoch characterized by an overabundance of heterogeneous information, the linear and authoritative nature of traditional books might be perceived as circumscribing. Benjamin’s embrace of incompleteness, digression, and fragmented narratives in his essays manifests a profound discernment for the intricacies inherent in our world. He apprehends that no solitary perspective can encapsulate the entirety of our experiences, and that veritable truth may reside in the juxtaposition of diverse voices and perspectives.

The methodological praxis of Walter Benjamin compels us to contemplate, with due gravity, the role of the audience in the interpretation of art. By availing himself of allegory-collage and montage techniques, he compels the audience to actively engage with the artwork, thereby eliciting their own conclusions. In this manner, Benjamin impugns the very notion of the passive observer, endowing the viewer with the mantle of an active participant. The act of “shocking” the audience with unanticipated associations disrupts complacency and nurtures an ethos of critical inquiry.

The palpable relevance of Benjamin’s ideas to the contemporary artistic landscape resonates with a profound resonance as I ponder them. In tandem with the burgeoningly interconnected and intricate tapestry of our society, it becomes patently apparent that novel modalities of expression and interpretation are imperative. Benjamin’s accentuation of the potency latent within fragments, collages, and essays aligns seamlessly with the fragmented nature of our digital epoch. His exploration of allegory-collage as a conduit for fostering novel understandings and subverting entrenched frameworks proffers an invaluable compass for navigating the labyrinthine nexus of information and meaning that envelops us.

The contributions of Walter Benjamin to the post-critical employment of allegory-collage and montage incontrovertibly inscribe themselves onto the annals of art criticism. His perspicacious grasp of the allegorical musings of German Baroque playwrights, coupled with his prescient apprehension of the artistic requisites characterizing the twentieth century, endure as a resonant and invigorating force within contemporary artistic praxis. Benjamin’s embrace of the essay, conjoined with his renunciation of conventional formats, impugns deeply ingrained norms and exhorts us to reevaluate our modus operandi in knowledge production. Through the medium of collage and montage, Benjamin bequeaths novel conduits for the interweaving of disparate elements, thereby engendering emergent insights. As they did during the span of Benjamin’s mortal sojourn, his ideas persist as founts of inspiration for artists, critics, and intellectuals navigating the convoluted passageways of our ever-shifting world.

Walter Benjamin, “The Origin of German Tragic Drama” (Germany)
Susan Buck-Morss, “The Dialectics of Seeing: Walter Benjamin and the Arcades Project” (United States)
Howard Eiland and Michael W. Jennings (eds.), “Walter Benjamin: A Critical Life” (United States)
Esther Leslie, “Walter Benjamin: Overpowering Conformism” (United Kingdom)
Gerhard Richter, “Walter Benjamin and the Corpus of Autobiography” (Germany)
Sigrid Weigel, “Body-and Image-Space: Re-reading Walter Benjamin” (Germany)
Peter Osborne, “Walter Benjamin: Critical Evaluations in Cultural Theory” (United Kingdom)
Andrew Benjamin, “Walter Benjamin and Art” (Australia)
Beatrice Hanssen, “Walter Benjamin’s Other History” (United States)
Esther Leslie, “Walter Benjamin: Overcoming Melancholy” (United Kingdom)